HOLUALOA — More than three and a half years after someone broke into Terry Lutterman’s storage shed and made off with boxes of the man’s antique coins, Lutterman said he has yet to see justice in the case.
HOLUALOA — More than three and a half years after someone broke into Terry Lutterman’s storage shed and made off with boxes of the man’s antique coins, Lutterman said he has yet to see justice in the case.
That’s despite Lutterman believing he knows exactly who’s responsible for the burglary and theft.
The loss is two-fold. There’s the monetary — Lutterman estimates the value at $200,000. But there’s also the sentimental dagger. Lutterman first inherited the coins from the couple who formerly owned the property on which he now lives — a couple who opened their doors to Lutterman when he moved in with them rent-free in 1983.
“I used to go over there all the time, used to play cards with them,” he said. “I kept ‘em company; that’s what I did … And I did it ‘cause I loved them.”
The coins, which the couple collected over many years and stowed away in old ammunition boxes, included old silver U.S. currency: everything from silver nickels and dimes to old silver dollars. They’d been carefully sorted, rolled and accounted for on a piece of paper inside each box.
“You know know long it took for those guys to save all that money?” Lutterman asked.
But face value alone doesn’t capture the worth of Lutterman’s collection. Many of the coins in the collection are prized for their high silver content, making them much more valuable than they are as currency.
The collection also included 40 Krugerrands, South African gold coins, alone worth $60,000, he said. Still, how they represent his friendship with the couple makes it all the worse.
“I loved both of them to the maximum,” said Lutterman, who moved to Hawaii in 1980 before moving three years later to the farm he now lives on.
The disappearance
In June 2013, Lutterman noticed that the locked door to the shed where he’d kept the ammunition boxes had been pried open.
Thirteen of the 23 ammunition boxes were gone, including all of the gold Krugerrands. A month after Lutterman discovered the coins had disappeared, he and a friend went to visit some coin shops in Hilo and a gold and silver buyer in Kona.
There, he said, his friend asked store staff if they knew the man Lutterman suspected of stealing the coins — a man Lutterman had let live on his property for several months before the coins started vanishing.
Store staff said they knew him, and that he came in many times with lots of silver.
The kicker was how the suspected thief transported the silver. In a couple cases, Lutterman said, the coins were carried in ammunition boxes — exactly like the ones that had been taken.
Lutterman provided West Hawaii Today with documents detailing all of his suspect’s alleged visits to coin stores and a gold buyer in Kona and Hilo. The dates of sales on the documents pre-date Lutterman’s discovery of the missing coins by months.
The records show a series of sales at three stores, sometimes as frequently as every week or every other week. Lutterman suspects the person who stole the coins was taking them long before he found the storage shed pried open.
One of the stores who bought the Krugerrands was Golden Egg Cash Assets, a Kailua-Kona gold and silver coin buyer. Store owner Michelle Johnson said she was shocked when she found out that the coins she’d been buying might have been stolen and were part of a police investigation.
Her store, she said, has an extensive vetting process to ensure every transaction is above board.
“Typically I ask a lot of questions,” she said. Those include questions about how long the seller’s had the wares and where it came from.
She also keeps a record of the identities of people who come in to sell goods. It’s only when she feels completely comfortable with the seller and verifies his or her identity that she moves forward with a purchase. She’s turned sellers away in the past.
“I’ve had many cases where I did not feel comfortable and I would tell them so,” she said. “I’d say ‘I’m so sorry; I do not feel comfortable purchasing this from you.’ And no one has given me a hard time about that at all.”
She also keeps reports of thefts on hand so she can keep an eye out when gold and silver come through her door.
She said she didn’t know the man suspected of stealing Lutterman’s coins before he first came to the store. When provided the alleged thief’s name and photograph, she said it matched that of the seller who sold her the coins.
“He came in and said that he was a coffee manager, managed coffee farms,” she said.
He needed to sell the coins, Johnson said, to be able to pay his workers.
Johnson said the man would typically come in with one or two coins at a time, telling the store that his grandfather had gifted him the coins before he passed away.
Over time, she said, they developed a business relationship with the man, with him coming in to sell one or two coins at a time. His name is being withheld, and he couldn’t be found for this story. Lutterman believes his one-time friend doesn’t have a fixed address.
Krugerrands, Johnson said, are common coins.
“And it always was around paying the coffee laborers,” she said.
Everything about the man who sold her the coins, Johnson said, looked and sounded legitimate.
“He looked like a farmer,” she said. “He came in like he came in from the fields working the farm.”
Johnson, who comes from a long line of coffee farmers, said the two of them would talk coffee when he came in. And in the several times the man came in to her store, she said, “the story was always same.”
It was a shock, then, when she found out the coins might have been stolen.
“When I found out about the case, I was so mortified and I felt taken,” she said. “Because we had developed trust and … a business relationship.”
Coins melted, sold, investigated
But by the time Lutterman and his friend visited the store, she said, she didn’t have any of the coins she’d purchased. The last recorded sale of coins to the store, according to Lutterman’s documents, was March 2013, three months before Lutterman reported the burglary to law enforcement.
Had they still been in her possession, she said, she would have returned them.
However, by the time Lutterman notified her about the case, it had already been months since the last sale. In that time, some of the coins were melted down and others had been resold.
She hasn’t seen the man who sold her the coins since, adding that he’s on her blacklist for the store.
Lutterman turned his findings over to law enforcement, but, he said, the result’s been anything but swift in the last three years.
In January 2014, the Office of the Prosecuting Attorney sent Lutterman a letter informing him that they received the police report in the case and that it was “being reviewed to determine if criminal charges can be pursued.”
About a month later, Lutterman said, the case was passed to a Hilo prosecutor before being passed again to another prosecutor in July 2015.
Lutterman said he’s called and called, but he’s seen no progress on his case.
“Oh, nothing yet,” he said of the response he hears when he calls.
Last April, Lutterman said, he spoke with the prosecutor handling the case, deputy prosecutor Ricky Damerville. At that time, he said, the prosecutor told him to “expect some papers for the grand jury.”
“Nothing happened,” Lutterman said.
Then in September, he said, he spoke with the prosecutor again. That time, Damerville told him he would take the case to a judge instead of a grand jury. But that’s the last time he heard from the prosecutor.
Lutterman said he can’t understand what’s taking so long.
“I don’t know why these guys are not doing anything about this,” he said. “Should’ve been done a long time ago.”
Damerville on Wednesday said there’s “likely to be some action soon,” and that the “nature of the facts” has caused the case to take as long as it has.
Johnson said she’s only been approached by police about the case once, when she was asked to identify the seller.
She said she was surprised to hear the case was even still open when a reporter contacted her about it.
“I’m very surprised that this has not been completed because I’ve helped a number of cases where I would be called as a professional witness,” she said.
Losing hope
At this point, Lutterman said, he’s concerned that the case could end up being too old to prosecute and he’ll never see justice done.
“I’m afraid it’s gonna be … too late,” he said. “That’s what I’m worried about.”
And if that ends up being the case?
“I’d be pissed,” he said. “I did everything. The cops didn’t have to do anything; I did everything.”
His ire though, isn’t with police, he cautioned, but with prosecutors, why it’s taking so long despite being told of progress from the office along the way.
At this point, he said, he doesn’t expect to get any money back. He does, however, hope to see whoever took the coins held accountable.
“I just want him to go to prison,” Lutterman said. “That’s where he belongs.”